Welcome to Tricycle Day. We’re the psychedelics newsletter that keeps tabs for you. Don’t lick your screen though. 😛
Our lunch convo got heated the other day.
One friend said LSD is “just” stronger mushrooms. Another said mushrooms are just weaker LSD. We countered that LSD is for people who wear Patagonia vests and mushrooms are for people who hike Patagonia.
But the real answer involves a lot more than potency and outerwear.
So for today’s newsletter, we asked our network of licensed psilocybin facilitators: What are the key differences between mushrooms and LSD?
Here’s how they broke it down.
| FROM OUR PARTNERS |
It’s really happening.
The FDA is now reviewing not one but two new drug applications for psilocybin. Both Compass and Usona have filed their paperwork.
We’re praying the FDA green lights them both.
But approval would be limited to treatment-resistant or major depression. That leaves out everyone coming for personal growth, well-being, grief, chronic pain… the list goes on.
The good news is, you don't have to wait on the FDA. Althea is already open to adults 21+, no diagnosis needed.
We’ve overseen 5,000+ psilocybin sessions, and 97% of participants called their experience beneficial.

Extended cut
Compared to psilocybin, a little LSD tends to go a long way. Terry Turner did the math: “A full-blown experience on mushrooms starts at about 20 mg of psilocybin. A full-blown dose with LSD starts at about 100 micrograms which means that LSD is roughly 200 times more powerful in terms of the amount of alkaloid needed to produce the effect.”
That tiny dose still stretches the day considerably. Masha Steiner-Renoir has timed it: “Mushrooms typically last 4–6 hours, while LSD can last 8–12 hours or longer.” Monica Ramunda adds a reality check: “That’s a significant commitment, especially when navigating emotionally challenging material.”
The long LSD day may have a kinder ending, at least. Sarah Mark describes the back half: “During this time many people experience a peak as well as a gentler descent where they are able to interact more easily with others.”
Are you in or out?
Psilocybin and lysergide may be chemical cousins, but they have unique personalities. Monica offers one way to tell them apart: “I sometimes think of psilocybin as an invitation to journey inward, while LSD can feel like an invitation to explore outward.”
The fungus has a sense of humor, too. Masha vouches for its character: “To me, mushrooms have a mischievous, playful spirit.” Terry has tried both and compares: “My own experiences with mushrooms tended to be milder and more somatic, whereas LSD is very heady and, I would say, telepathic and cosmic.”
But don’t get too attached to the dividing lines. Clayton Ickes keeps the contrast in perspective: “LSD tends to produce less gastrointestinal discomfort and be a bit more psychological in the way that it presents, while psilocybin tends to feel a little bit more embodied and earthy (though there is much more overlap than difference in truth).”
Know before you go
The medicine you choose is, of course, only part of the story. Amy Charlesworth explains what the comparison leaves out: “People describe the experiences differently, but those descriptions are subjective and can change depending on the person, amount, mindset, and setting.”
Then there’s the law. Sarah says Colorado splits the two by origin: “LSD is not legalized in any state at this time as it is a synthetic psychedelic, rather than a plant-based medicine, which is how the Natural Medicine Health Act determines which substances are allowed.”
But when the goal is healing, we don’t have to crown a winner. Kate Schroeder explains how she sees it: “From a therapeutic perspective, I’m less interested in declaring one medicine better than the other and more interested in understanding which experience might be appropriate for a particular person.”
Our take
The simplistic comparison for these two medicines often boils down to natural vs. synthetic.
That framing can make you pick a side real quick if you have even the slightest granola leanings.
But hey, not so fast. Psilocybin actually goes both ways. Psygen cofounder Danny Motyka makes the synthetic kind for a living. Pharma favors precision, he says, so 99% pure psilocybin makes sense there.
LSD, on the other hand, only ships from the lab. There’s no plant or fungus you can extract it from.
Besides, lab-made doesn’t have to mean devoid of soul. Legendary underground chemist Leonard Pickard described making LSD as a sacrament. He’d meditate beforehand, then light votive candles and blast Gregorian chants while he worked. (This is the way.)
So to be fair, “natural” only tells you where something came from. It says jack squat about what it’ll do to you.
Poison ivy is all-natural too, y’all.
Thanks to Herb H. from Newmarket, ON for submitting this week’s question. 🫠
Got a question for our guides?
Reply to this email to shoot your shot. If it’s a juicy one, we may select it for a future issue.
! UNTIL NEXT TIME !
That’s all for today, Cyclists! Whenever you’re ready, here’s how we can help.
🍄🟫 Experience psilocybin
Browse our curated marketplace of legally operated and professionally guided psilocybin experiences.
🫂 Integrate your journey
Join our free integration community for help turning profound insights into lasting change.
🧑💻 Run your licensed psilocybin practice
Sign up for Althea to manage clients, schedule sessions, collect payments, and stay in compliance.
👕 Shop merch
Collect a tee and advocate for psychedelics in style.
! ONE CYCLIST’S REVIEW !

So, how was your tricycle ride?
Forwarded this email? Subscribe here.
DISCLAIMER: This newsletter is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice. The use, possession, and distribution of psychedelic drugs are illegal in most countries and may result in criminal prosecution.





